Comments on 2019 Revised Patent Subject Matter Eligibility Guidance

March 8, 2019

File Downloads

All documents are in PDF format.

AIPLA applauds the Office for providing a valuable guide for determining patent eligibility and is grateful to the Office for providing what AIPLA believes is a better framework for analyzing subject matter eligibility than was provided by the multiple previous guidance documents. We also appreciate that the Office is providing public access to the examiner training materials as these provide a common framework for understanding how to apply the Guidance. AIPLA is also pleased that the Guidance applies to the PTAB as well as to the examination groups and believes that this will result in a more uniform handling of issues concerning patent-eligible subject matter. AIPLA notes that the Guidance provides a framework for analyzing patent eligibility based on a distillation of the current Supreme Court and Federal Circuit case law covering many different disciplines and, thus, the framework is necessarily imprecise.

AIPLA suggests that further guidance be included with respect to claims directed to diagnostic methods, as the current Guidance does not explicitly address such claims. If the USPTO did not intend to provide guidance for diagnostic method claims, we believe it will be helpful to affirmatively indicate that this January 7, 2019 Guidance does not apply to diagnostic methods.

Upcoming Events

  • Partnering in Patents - Mechanical Arts

    November 13, 2024 8:30 AM to 4:45 PM   |   No CLE

    Learn and share ideas about mechanical disciplines at the Technology Centers (TC) 3600 and 3700 and American Intellectual Property Law Association (AIPLA) Customer Partnership Meeting on Wednesday, November 13, from 8:30 a.m. to 4:45 p.m. ET, at the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) headquarters in Alexandria, Virginia. The meeting will feature perspectives from USPTO examiners, practitioners, and the industry, focusing on better examiner-practitioner interactions for high-quality patents. We'll address topics such as: Artificial intelligence (AI) subject matter eligibility USPTO search tools Drafting patent specifications Approaches to examiner interviews in the mechanical arts
  • 2025 Leadership Forum

    January 29 to 30, 2025

    AIPLA Leadership Forum – Elevate Yourself, Inspire the Future. This invitation-only two-day program will address building strong leadership skills for all levels of experience. More details coming soon.
  • 2025 AIPLA Spring Meeting

    May 13 to 15, 2025

    Save the Date! The 2025 Spring Meeting is a 2.5 day conference focused on trending topics in IP law. Registration opens February 2025.