Cuozzo Speed Technologies, LLC v. Lee, U.S., No. 15-446, amicus brief filed 3/7/2016
File Downloads
All documents are in PDF format.
The Federal Circuit erred in endorsing the PTAB’s use of the broadest reasonable interpretation (BRI) standard for claim construction in AIA trial proceedings, AIPLA argued to the Supreme Court in a March 7, 2016 amicus brief.
The BRI standard was specially crafted for examinational proceedings, not for the adjudicative proceedings created by the AIA. Congress intended those adjudicative proceedings to be an efficient alternative to district court trials, according to the brief, and they should follow the Phillips/Markman standard for claim construction used in district courts. The amicus brief also argued that the Federal Circuit incorrectly bars appellate consideration of issues raised in the PTAB final written decision when those issues were also addressed in the PTAB decision to institute the AIA trial. The Court’s misinterpretation of the bar on appeals at 35 U.S.C. §314(d) conflicts with the presumption of judicial review of executive branch actions.
The BRI standard was specially crafted for examinational proceedings, not for the adjudicative proceedings created by the AIA. Congress intended those adjudicative proceedings to be an efficient alternative to district court trials, according to the brief, and they should follow the Phillips/Markman standard for claim construction used in district courts. The amicus brief also argued that the Federal Circuit incorrectly bars appellate consideration of issues raised in the PTAB final written decision when those issues were also addressed in the PTAB decision to institute the AIA trial. The Court’s misinterpretation of the bar on appeals at 35 U.S.C. §314(d) conflicts with the presumption of judicial review of executive branch actions.
Upcoming Events
-
2025 IP Practice in Japan Pre-Meeting - Rancho Mirage, CA
January 27 to 28, 2025
The IP Practice in Japan Committee is planning a pre-meeting before the 2025 Leadership Forum. The program will run a full-day on Monday, January 27 and in the morning for half-day on Tuesday, January 28. -
2025 Leadership Forum
January 29 to 30, 2025
AIPLA Leadership Forum – Elevate Yourself, Inspire the Future. This invitation-only two-day program will address building strong leadership skills for all levels of experience. More details coming soon. -
2025 AIPLA Spring Meeting
May 13 to 15, 2025
Save the Date! The 2025 Spring Meeting is a 2.5 day conference focused on trending topics in IP law. Registration opens February 2025.